What are the differences between disneys pocahontas and the. Pocahontas and benjamin franklin are two extraordinary americans whose lives have been recounted in historical works, novels, plays, and film. Pocahontas saves john smithss life according to a record written by john smith. Disney s pocahontas movie is speaking a different story, but pocahontas and john smith are just friends. Differences between the reallife pocahontas and the movie. There are a great many differences between the pocahontas movie and the real thing. But does the commemorative statue honor her real life.
In an essay compare and contrast how historical developments influenced their respective experiences and outlooks. Pocahontas is remembered as the powhatan native american woman who saved the life of englishman john smith and married john rolfe. Pocahontas was a daughter of a chief, and thus, received special treatments in contrast to other women in their tribe. Pocahontas was a native american famous for her association with english colonists during their first years in virginia. They are still based off of a similar place and time in history, which causes them to have certain similarities. The pocahontas movie lead watchers to believe that most interactions were peaceful or nonviolent. Being that pocahontas was really just eleven years old in real life and then being portrayed in the movie as this older, beautiful woman with long black shiny hair and wears a short dress which reveals a lot of her body skin.
Although pocahontas was based on a person who existed in real life, the events in the film were actually all fictionalized. Around 1610, pocahontas, then around 14 years old, married kocoum, possibly of the patawomeck tribe, whom the two would live among for a short time. The name matoaka was never mentioned in the first movie. Difference and similarities between the movie and the real. Jun 21, 2018 smith claimed pocahontas twice saved his life in his 1624 book general historie of virginia, long after many of the main players had passed away. Pocahontas isnt an amovie in the disney catalog, but its a solid secondtier film that, despite its romanticizing of the noble savage, nonetheless features themes that are wholesome and. I need you to expand on these answers if you want a higher grade. Despite similarities, pocahontas gets love, malinche gets hate. Learn by example and become a better writer with kibins suite of essay help services.
There are similarities between the history of it and movie, but theres also differences. In the disney movie, john smith and pocahontas met in the wilderness and fell in love, kind of like romeo and juliet. Pocahontas might be a household name, but the true story of her short. Animated adam paints with all the colors of the truth to illustrate the real story of pocahontas. History disneys pocahontas is a great movie, but is it historically correct. Pocahontas was born as the daughter of matka of pobatan, the head of the pobatan tribe. Watch allnew episodes of adam ruins everything presents. Pocahontas obviously did not communicate with animals in real life, either.
Unfortunately, there are little accounts regarding the upbringing of pocahontas prior to reaching the proper age. John smith and pocahontas movie vs real life by mr. This is called intertextuality, when two texts, or films in this case, have similarities. I took a course in the history of film animation and i remember. Disney movie vs history film studies essay uk essays. Both the native american females and males are being gender stereotyped in this movie. Your grade will be a 60 or 70 if you just copy my answers. According to history, pocahontas changed her name to rebecca when she converted to christianity. Most of them movies have the real names from the history but their story is. Much of pocahontas life has been romanticized and sensationalized in movies and books. For instance, it makes a concerted effort to make the point that john smiths rescue is part of a ritual and not a real threat on his life.
Spoiler alert avatar, while visually a stunning movie especially in 3d was, at first viewing, a very similar plot to disneys pocahontas which is not historically accurate, but that is for a different post. The disney version of pocahontas and the real story have many differences such as the romance, pocahontas personality. The real pocahontas early life to adulthood, real name matoaka. Difference and similarities between the movie and the real life of pocahontas similarities the setting jamestown, virginia started to look for gold when the colonists arrived to jamestown. But here are all the ways that disney changed the real story. Pocahontas even starts a romance with smith, and the two almost sail away to britain together at the end of the film. Disneys pocahontas in real life pocahontas and john smith were both young adults when they met. However, pocahontas was a real woman who lived during a pivotal time of first contact kilpatrick 2.
The true story of pocahontas as not told by disney ancient. Pocahontas was a native american famous for her association with english colonists during their first years. In the disney movie, pocahontas meets john smith when they were both about the same age. Pocahontas was a nickname given to her father meaning playful one. Pocahontas there are many differences between the real story of pocahontas and disneys interpretation of pocahontas. Similarities between pocahontas and disneys animated movie. The true story of pocahontas is sadder and less romantic than. Governor ratcliffe and chief powhatan where a good representation. Learn about the historic powhatan indian princess pocahontas.
The disney movie portrays pocahontas placing her head. In real life her love interest was john raul and in the movie her love interest was john smith. Pocahontas is a 1995 american animated musical romantic drama film loosely based on the life of the native american woman pocahontas. One drawback is that this particular event takes up a great deal of this movie, along with the building of the friendship between smith and the young pocahontas. Despite similarities, pocahontas gets love, malinche gets. Maybe the authors drew inspiration from real life events or from each other. In a true relation of virginia 1608, smith described meeting pocahontas in the spring of 1608 when she was a child of ten years old. Mar 02, 2019 statue of pocahontas in historic jamestowne, virginia, usa. By comparing the disneys pocahontas to her reallife counterpart using four. Mar 27, 2018 animated adam paints with all the colors of the truth to illustrate the real story of pocahontas.
While there are similarities between the real pocahontas and the movie, there are also many differences. Pocahontas the difference and similarities between. She was born in the 1600s and now is jamestown, virginia. In real life, pocahontas was a member of the pamunkey tribe in virginia.
The movie ends before pocahontas marries john rolfe. Oct 19, 2015 besides the fact the pocahontas wasnt even her real name. The true story of pocahontas as not told by disney ancient origins. In both versions, t he setting is 1607 in jamestown, virginia and the surrounding area.
Instead of marrying her fiance kocoum in the movie, pocahontas decides to run off with john smith, while in real life, pocahontas runs off with john rolfe to america and gets married and has kids. The most easily recognized similarity is of that john smith is in both the movie and narrative. Jun 01, 2009 well, in real life pocahontas was a lot younger, and john smith a lot older, than they are portrayed as being in the film. The real story of pocahontas is much darker than the disney movie. John smith was tall, clean shaven, and blonde in the movie while he was short, bearded, and had black hair in real life. The given name of pocahontas was matoaka in real life, which means bright stream between the hills, while pocahontas was her nickname. Nov 25, 2015 despite similarities, pocahontas gets love, malinche gets hate.
Statue of pocahontas in historic jamestowne, virginia, usa. Pocahontas was the first animated movie of the disney, which was based on history. Another difference is that john smith did not have the same physical appearance as he did in the movie. In writing this essay consider the following questions. Similarities between pocahontas the movie and real life essay.
The truth behind 5 disney movies that are based on real. The story of pocahontas disneyfied, or disney tried. Wikimedia the real story of pocahontas would make a greater movie than the one produced by disney, as her tragic life. Pocahontas s birth year is unknown, but some historians estimate it to have been around 1596. A comparison between disney movie pocahontas free essays. What is the difference between the disney pocahontas movie. Pocahontas was actually about eleven or twelve when the two met. The true story of pocahontas history smithsonian magazine. The story and movie both are about a young native american girl from the region we now call virginia.
The similarities and differences of pocahontas and her. Disney actually approached her as a consultant on the film, an offer she flatly refused. While the second movie introduced her real husband, john. But written accounts and native american oral history show she lived a brief yet significant life. There were many pocahontas facts circulating with different. The movie encourages children to perform similar wonderwomanlike feats, rather than being a strong and realistic woman in todays world rosenzweig. The true story of pocahontas as not told by disney. Yet historical developments beyond their control shaped their life experiences. What are the differences between disneys pocahontas and. Aug 29, 2011 the first thing is that smith wasnt the dashing leader that the cartoon makes him out to be. Well, in real life pocahontas was a lot younger, and john smith a lot older, than they are portrayed as being in the film. Difference and similarities between the movie and the real l. What are the differences and similarities between avatar and.
192 1096 495 1164 994 700 959 1004 988 810 205 999 1237 304 1316 2 1166 1011 506 907 435 469 843 1499 136 528 1146 342 812 1220 979 152 552 276 1267 570 920 170 534 308 293 89 681 205 1492